On Tuesday 10 November 2026 the Mount Pleasant Mine Bill 2026 was introduced into the NSW Legislative Assembly.
The Bill has been proposed by the NSW Government following the High Court’s decision of 7 October 2026 in MACH Energy Australia Pty Ltd v Denman Aberdeen Muswellbrook Scone Healthy Environment Group Inc & Anor [2026] HCA 35. This decision found the Independent Planning Commission (IPC) had not properly considered scope 3 emissions when approving the 2022 expansion and the matter needed to be remitted back the Land and Environment Court NSW to consider new orders on the mining application.
EDO opposes the Bill because it risks bypassing the Land and Environment Court’s reconsideration and the ordinary planning process, as well as eroding the rule of law, the separation of powers and public trust in independent decision-making.
Read EDO’s Legal Update when the Bill was proposed here.
In summary, the Bill:
- authorises coal mining by MACH Energy outside of the planning law process, providing MACH Energy with authority to keep mining at up to 16.5 million tonnes a year until 2032 (clauses 5 and 6).
- provides that mining must occur in accordance with “statutory conditions” that will be Gazetted, which should include conditions for greenhouse gas emissions, including scope 3 emissions (the central issue in the High Court case), along with other matters (clauses 3(c), 4(1) and 5(1)(b)). These proposed conditions have not yet been published.
- provides a very broad Henry VIII clause which enables Regulations, a subordinate instrument, to modify the application of any Act or instrument to the authorised development (clause 17). This circumvents the ordinary process of parliamentary scrutiny and debate.
- threatens to override the pending process and decision of the Land and Environment Court of NSW by effectively limiting the operation of any development consent decided by the Court until either 2033 or upon MACH Energy surrendering the authorisation provided under the Bill if that occurs earlier (clause 7).This appears to be contrary to the Bill at Schedule 1 Part 2, section 2 which claims the Act will not affect proceedings pending in a Court.
- prevents accountability mechanisms such as review or challenges of the authority, through a privative clause that prevents any proceedings being brought to review or challenge the authorisation of mining provided for by the Bill (clause 8).
- makes the Planning Minister the consent authority for the approval, not the Independent Planning Commission (clause 6).
- authorises a “jobs guarantee agreement” to be entered by the Resources Minister with a mining party to require employment of a certain number of people for the authorised development (clause 10).
- provides a stop order power: enabling the Minister to stop authorised development if the mining party does not enter the jobs guarantee agreement or contravenes the agreement (clause 15).
The Bill is expected to be voted on shortly without any inquiry process for public comment.
EDO’s recommendations for reform:
Ideally this Bill would not be passed by the NSW Parliament given the significant risks it poses, as outlined above.
If not withdrawn, EDO recommends the following amendments to remove the most egregious of risks posed by the Bill in exposing discretionary powers without accountability:
- Remove the overreaching Henry VIII clause which provides broad powers to use Regulations to displace the application of any Act or instrument to the authorised development. This is a highly unusual overreach of powers being provided to make changes to the way the mining operations will be regulated going forward without sufficient public or parliamentary oversight. These powers should only be provided in highly exceptional circumstances. No reasons have been provided as to why these powers are needed here. The Australian Law Reform Commission has stated that Henry VIII clauses are considered ‘inappropriate’.
- Amend clause 7 to ensure the Bill does not override any future decisions, including of the Land and Environment Court of NSW, to ensure proper planning law and court processes are respected.
- Publish a draft of the “statutory conditions” to be attached to the Mount Pleasant mine authorisation before debating the Bill, where otherwise Parliament is expected to debate and vote on the authorisation of a mining activity with no visibility of what the conditions that will be attached to that authority will be.
- Commit to public consultation on the technical guidance document for proposed scope 3 conditions to apply to future coal mining applications, noting this technical guidance is expected to be attached to the NSW Coal Industry 2026-50 policy document.
- Reduce the amount of coal permitted to be mined under the authorisation, where there has not been clear evidence provided to demonstrate a need for this quantity of coal given existing approvals.
The 2022 IPC approval allowed Mount Pleasant to extend to 2048 and increase annual production from 10.5 to 21 million tonnes. The Denman Aberdeen Muswellbrook Scone Healthy Environment Group (DAMS HEG) succeeded in the NSW Court of Appeal, and MACH Energy appealed to the High Court.
The High Court majority held that a consent authority must actively consider scope 3 (downstream) emissions, including whether conditions should be imposed to authorise them as far as practicable, and that the IPC had not done so. The High Court has ordered that the application must return to the Land and Environment Court to decide whether to suspend the consent in whole or part, and to specify terms for compliance to validate the consent. The Land and Environment Court will continue to hear this matter, regardless of the Bill being passed.
Separately, on 14 August 2026 the Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure approved a modification extending the mine’s life to 2032 and lifting output from 10.5 to 12.5 million tonnes a year.
However, media reports warn that MACH Energy may have been illegally increasing operations since the IPC’s initial decision in 2022 beyond approved limits, even after the decision of the NSW Court of Appeal to invalidate the IPC’s approval. EDO understands that an investigation into this matter has commenced.
EDO’s concerns
As outlined in EDO’s last legal update when the Bill was announced, EDO has significant concerns about the precedent this Bill sets, risking eroding public trust, integrity and good governance in NSW mining decision-making.
Rule of law and separation of powers. The High Court identified a legality problem with the Mount Pleasant mine application decision-making process and set out a path to correct it. A project-specific Bill that partly bypasses that reconsideration risks undercutting that outcome. The Court is the appropriate forum to balance the effect of the decision against urgency and uncertainty, as it holds a discretion over the orders that follow.
Sweeping powers introduced without accountability protections. The Bill provides the power to amend laws applying to the Mount Pleasant mine going forward via Regulations, which are typically not subject to public oversight nor parliamentary debate processes.
Weak justification. Reportedly there has been inadequate evidence demonstrating that job losses are imminent to justify this Bill, particularly given recent further approvals have been granted out to 2032.
Conditions yet to be seen. The Bill creates the power to gazette applicable conditions for the authorise mining, however EDO has not yet seen these conditions. The conditions are a fundamental element of the authorisation and should be disclosed in draft form to members of parliament and the community prior to the Bill being debated.
Possible past non-compliance. Media reports suggest the mine may have operated above approved limits since 2022, including after the Court of Appeal’s decision, and EDO understands an investigation has commenced. If this is the case, special treatment through the Bill is even harder to justify and sends a dangerous signal to industry and community that non-compliance will be brushed aside and even rewarded.
Poor precedent. Ad hoc legislation after an adverse court decision weakens incentives for careful primary decision-making, respect for the independent court process and public trust in the planning framework.
What to watch and how to have your concerns heard
- Passage through the Legislative Assembly and Legislative Council, and any amendments is expected to be quick. Contact your state member of parliament today to let them know your concerns.
- Keep an eye out for:
- Publication of the conditions by gazette, including as to scope 3 emissions.
- The Land and Environment Court’s reconsideration, reportedly expected to resume in December 2026.
- Amendments to the NSW Coal Industry 2026-50 policy document to introduce a new appendix providing scope 3 emissions conditions for all future coal mining applications, as referred to in the NSW Government media release.
- Any investigation outcome on allegedly illegal mining undertaken by MACH Energy.




